Malcolm Turnbull refuses to admit blame for Snowy Hydro 2.0

Advertisement

When former Liberal Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull first announced the Snowy Hydro 2.0 pumped hydro project in 2017, it was billed as a $2 billion project capable of producing 2 gigawatts of power on demand and 350,000 megawatt-hours of storage by 2021.

Snowy Hydro 2.0 has been delayed several times since its announcement, with its latest cost estimate blowing out to $25 billion, more than 10 times its initially announced cost.

Including associated transmission infrastructure and other costs required to get power to and from the project, the total system cost of Snowy Hydro 2.0 will now easily exceed $40 billion and will likely rank as one of the most expensive energy projects in the world.

Despite the enormous costs associated with Snowy Hydro 2.0, Malcolm Turnbull, now president of the International Hydropower Association, continues to tout the project as being “good value for money” and vital to Australia’s energy future.

Advertisement

“I remain of the view that the project remains good value for money”, Turnbull wrote in The Australian. “The need for storage, including pumped hydro, is greater than ever. The comparable cost for this amount of storage with batteries would be at least $100bn and would not bring the many ancillary grid security benefits that hydro delivers”.

“It will be one of the world’s largest energy storage projects and essential to the clean energy transition, where most of our primary generation will come from variable sources of wind and solar, which are today the cheapest way to generate electricity”.

Malcolm Turnbull is drinking the Kool Aid. Pumped hydroelectric projects like Snowy Hydro 2.0 create no net power. They merely store excess renewable energy (mostly solar) generated in the middle of the day for use when it is required.

Advertisement

The likely $40 billion-plus price tag of Snowy Hydro 2.0, plus associated transmission and other costs, could instead have delivered a fleet of baseload generators that produce power 24/7 whenever required, without needing storage.

Thanks to Turnbull’s blunder on Snowy Hydro 2.0, Australian energy costs and taxes will have to rise to pay for what is shaping up to be one of the world’s biggest renewable energy boondoggles.

Professor Bruce Mountain believes Snowy Hydro 2.0 is “one of the biggest disasters” in Australian infrastructure history:

Advertisement

If you don’t believe my criticisms, consider the expert testimony of Professor Bruce Mountain, a prominent figure in energy economics and the inaugural Director of the Victoria Energy Policy Centre at Victoria University.

Mountain has warned repeatedly over many years that Snowy Hydro 2.0 is an expensive boondoggle that should be abandoned.

In April this year, Professor Bruce Mountain and former energy executive Ted Woodley estimated that Snowy Hydro 2.0 could cost another $10 billion to build and $42 billion, accounting for transmission and other costs.

Advertisement

Mountain said that Snowy 2.0 was a “dreadful idea” from the outset and called it “one of the biggest disasters” in Australian infrastructure history. He also called for a royal commission into the troubled project.

Mountain’s recent interview with 7News also expertly explained why Snowy Hydro 2.0 is a failure in every conceivable way.

Advertisement

Mountain said that he always warned that the project would “be an utter failure from the outset… It’s utterly frustrating and disheartening to see the sheer waste of public wealth and of natural resource in something which was so completely unavoidable”.

Beyond the enormous costs, the project won’t even deliver flexible storage because it could take months to pump water to the top dam. Then, once it is used, it would take months to pump it upstream again.

He said that the government could have built loads of gas peaker plants to cover wind droughts at a far cheaper cost, as well as other generation. He also lamented the environmental damage done to the Snowy Mountains from the project.

Advertisement

Mountain also suggested that the best course of action may be to abandon Snowy Hydro 2.0, given it would cost at least another $12 billion to build and won’t deliver the claimed benefits.

Modelling by consultant GHD supports this view, suggesting that Snowy Hydro 2.0 will deliver only around $7 billion in reductions to wholesale energy prices over its first 45 years of generating electricity. Thus, the additional $12 billion cost of completing the project, let alone the associated transmission costs, far exceeds its benefits.

Snowy Hydro 2.0 represents everything that is wrong with Australia: endemic waste and mismanagement of public funds, a complete lack of accountability, and failing upwards.

Advertisement

The least Malcolm Turnbull could have done was admit he made a mistake and spare us another arse-covering lecture.

About the author
Leith van Onselen is Chief Economist at the MB Fund and MB Super. He is also a co-founder of MacroBusiness. Leith has previously worked at the Australian Treasury, Victorian Treasury and Goldman Sachs.
Advertisement