Abandon Snowy Hydro 2.0 before it’s too late
The Snowy 2.0 pumped hydro project is emerging as Australia’s biggest single engineering disaster.
When former Liberal Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull first announced the project in 2017, it was projected to cost $2 billion and, by 2021, would produce 2 gigawatts of power on demand and 350,000 megawatt-hours of storage.
Snowy Hydro 2.0 has been delayed several times since its announcement, with its latest build cost estimated at $25 billion, more than 10 times its initially announced cost.
Including associated transmission infrastructure and other costs required to get power to and from the project, the total system cost of Snowy Hydro 2.0 will now easily exceed $40 billion and will likely rank as one of the most expensive energy projects in the world.
According to Robert Gottliebsen at The Australian, the word from the high country is that the total cost of Snowy 2.0 could ultimately be around $75 billion, with construction costs alone at $40-50 billion, which is 37 times the project’s original estimate of just $2 billion.
Gottliebsen cites the following causes for Snowy Hydro 2.0’s cost blow-out:
- Poor project planning and feasibility assessment.
- Underestimating the geological challenges of tunnelling through the Long Plain Fault Zone, described as some of the most difficult ground conditions encountered on the project.
- Contracting problems, including the failure of the original fixed-price arrangement.
- Industrial relations costs associated with the CFMEU.
- Political support from both major parties without adequate scrutiny.
Moreover, he says that Snowy Hydro 2.0 exposes the broader flaws in Australia’s climate and energy policy, namely:
- Political leaders have pursued renewable-energy targets and deadlines without adequately assessing costs.
- The project highlights the risks of large government-led decarbonisation initiatives.
- Alternative investments, particularly gas-fired power stations located near demand centres, could have delivered similar electricity system benefits at much lower cost.
While every Australian taxpayer will be required to pay the bill for Snowy Hydro 2.0, NSW in particular may face additional costs.
To end the chaos, Gottiebsen argues we need world-class independent engineers to properly evaluate the project’s cost and viability.
Abandon Snowy Hydro 2.0 before it is too late:
The common thinking around Snowy Hydro 2.0 is that because we have already sunk $12 billion into the project, it should continue.
This line of thinking is a classic example of the “sunk cost fallacy”, since the circa $12 billion cost of completing the project, assuming the government’s latest cost estimate is correct (a big ‘if’), is around six times more than the project’s initially announced cost.
Given that Snowy Hydro 2.0 would never have been approved at an initial price tag of $12 billion, it makes little sense to continue now that its cost has doubled again to around $25 billion, with the risk of further escalation. There are also enormous transmission costs to consider.
Moreover, modelling by consultant GHD suggests that Snowy Hydro 2.0 will deliver only around $7 billion in reductions to wholesale energy prices over its first 45 years of generating electricity. Therefore, the additional circa $12 billion cost of completing the project, let alone the associated transmission costs, far exceeds its benefits.
Given the project’s estimated costs and the risks of further increases, Snowy Hydro 2.0 must be abandoned before it wastes more scarce taxpayer money.
